Icebreakers become the new measure of Arctic power
As Arctic ice retreats, nations race to build, operate and deploy icebreakers. Capability gaps could determine who controls the region.

GIS Radio
Listen to our AI-powered podcast for comprehensive insights.
- Russia leads Arctic militarization with a new series of combat icebreakers
- China’s icebreakers are mainly research ships that cannot break thick ice
- The U.S. has one heavy icebreaker, the 50 year-old Polar Star
The melting of Arctic ice has set off a scramble that includes a once-unlikely contender: China. Powerful icebreakers are now symbols of status and prowess. With Russia operating a large icebreaker fleet and the United States possessing just one, the White House concluded that it could no longer tolerate such an icebreaker gap. Finland, as a leading builder of these vessels, was well placed to meet that need. In October 2025, Washington and Helsinki signed an agreement under which the U.S. Coast Guard will acquire 11 “Arctic Security Cutters.”
Judging whether this makes sense means asking three questions: Who needs icebreakers and for what; who can build them; and who can operate in heavy ice?

Why the Arctic race runs on icebreakers
The main purpose of icebreakers is to keep frozen sea lanes open for commercial traffic. For four northern countries – Canada, Finland, Russia and Sweden – this is imperative. For Russia, the challenge extends beyond the Arctic coastline, where ice obstructs access to ports crucial for exporting minerals and hydrocarbons; the Gulf of Finland must also remain navigable for ships bound for St. Petersburg. In Finland, ice can block access to every seaport, while in Sweden, all ports north of Stockholm freeze in winter. Canada must keep lanes open not only along its ocean coasts but also throughout the Northwest Passage and on the St. Lawrence River and Great Lakes.
All four nations are developing state-operated icebreaker fleets. Russia has around 40 such vessels, of which eight are nuclear-powered giants. Canada has 18, of which two are heavy Arctic icebreakers. Finland has eight and Sweden five. Three other countries fall outside this pattern. Norway relies on the North Atlantic Current, an extension of the Gulf Stream, which keeps its main seaports open, and operates two icebreakers to ensure access to Svalbard, its northern archipelago.
As an aspiring Arctic power, China put its fifth icebreaker into service at the end of 2024. The U.S. has a single heavy icebreaker, the 50 year-old Polar Star, which spends much of its time in dry dock for repairs and refurbishment.
Icebreaking also supports Arctic offshore drilling. That Arctic ice is melting does not mean there are open seas. Vessels navigating Arctic waters face challenges from both drifting icebergs and ice floes – flat expanses of floating sea ice that can vary in size from just a few meters to more than 10 kilometers across. A collision with an iceberg or a heavy ice floe could be disastrous for a stationary drilling platform.
The solution lies in Anchor Handling Tug Supply (AHTS) vessels. Built and operated by private firms, these are large oceangoing vessels with massive engine power, specialized hulls and wide working decks. Their services include towing drilling platforms into position, handling the heavy anchors that hold them in place, carrying supplies from the mainland and responding to fires or oil spills. Above all, their icebreaking capability lets them ward off dangers from floating ice. As melting Arctic ice has prompted both Russia and Norway to expand Arctic drilling, the importance of AHTS vessels has increased.
Number of major icebreakers and ice-capable patrol ships, 2022
A third purpose is polar research. Heavy icebreakers often operate alone on such missions. The Norwegian Polar Institute owns one of Norway’s two icebreakers, and the Swedish Polar Research Secretariat regularly charters the flagship of the Swedish icebreaker fleet. Finland has several vessels used for polar research, and China’s icebreakers are more accurately classed as polar research vessels.
The fourth and final need for icebreakers arises from the ongoing militarization of the Arctic. Until now, military activity in the Arctic has largely taken place either in the air or under the ice. Although submarines occasionally surface through the ice, naval surface operations in the Arctic are a new development, and the Kremlin is taking an early lead in developing heavily armed icebreakers.
Finland dominates icebreaker building
The second question, who can build heavy icebreakers, has a definitive answer. Although Russia has the largest fleet in operation, Finland holds an unquestioned lead in building such vessels. Around 60 percent of all existing icebreakers were built in Finland, and 80 percent are based on Finnish designs. Unsurprisingly, then, America turned to Finland for its order of 11 Arctic Security Cutters. The first four will be built in Finland and the rest in the U.S. in cooperation with Finnish partners.
Russia’s main strength lies in nuclear-powered icebreakers. It is the only country that operates them, and their brute force and endurance have been vital to keeping ports on the Arctic shoreline accessible. Because many of its older non-nuclear vessels are becoming obsolete, the current fleet cannot meet demand. Moscow has launched an ambitious shipbuilding program, but Western sanctions are disrupting it. The new Lider class was to comprise three ships, designed to be the world’s largest and most powerful icebreakers and capable of breaking ice four meters thick. In 2023, Russia cut the order to one, the Rossiya, which is far behind schedule. Originally due in 2027, it is now expected around 2029. Even the next ship of its proven Project 22220 class, the Chukotka, has slipped from 2026 to 2027. Rising costs are impeding construction and renewal across the board, forcing Russia to extend the service life of older vessels.
Yet Russia remains ahead in one area of construction: the development of heavily armed icebreakers. The first in a series of four “combat icebreakers” was commissioned in September 2025. These ships are armed, dual-use military and polar-class vessels designed to break through frozen sea ice while carrying naval armaments and missile systems.
Canada is pursuing a sweeping icebreaker renewal program, partly in response to the Russian military buildup. It plans to build six new icebreakers, all in Quebec. China is also expanding its icebreaker construction, and it built at least three of its current icebreakers domestically. Although much is made of Chinese interest in the Northern Sea Route (NSR), these vessels are better described as research ships because they lack the power to break very thick ice.
When Sweden decided to acquire a new Baltic icebreaker, turning to Finland seemed inevitable given the close security ties between the two neighbors. Instead, the contract went to South Korea’s HD Hyundai Heavy Industries, which has limited experience in this field. By declining to pay a premium for a Finnish-built icebreaker, the Swedish government risks undercutting its standing as a leading nation in ice navigation.

Icebreakers alone cannot open Arctic shipping lanes
The third and key question is who can operate in heavy ice. Running a lone nuclear icebreaker through heavy ice makes for impressive footage and may suffice for tasks such as polar research. But powerful icebreakers are far from enough to keep frozen sea lanes open. The vessels they support must also be built to navigate heavy ice.
States that operate icebreakers have therefore laid down rules for the ships they assist. The requirements cover engine power, specialized bows, protected steering gear that will not be damaged in broken ice and reinforced hulls that can withstand the pressure if the ship becomes trapped. Ships without a sufficient ice class do not qualify for icebreaker assistance. The race to build heavy icebreakers must therefore go hand in hand with building ice-class tankers and cargo vessels to operate with icebreaker support.
Read more by Professor Stefan Hedlund
- A ‘Danish Model’ for Ukraine
- Who holds the cards in Arctic security?
- Russia’s next Baltic move may not be invasion
Russia faces mounting problems here, with specialized tankers failing to reach Arctic destinations. Moscow also has issues affecting Arctic drilling operations. Before Russia’s 2014 annexation of Crimea, Exxon Mobil partnered with Russia’s Rosneft in a major offshore project in which outside contractors provided essential support, including AHTS vessels. U.S. sanctions imposed in September 2014 halted drilling in the Kara Sea, and Exxon formally exited the venture in 2018. Cut off from Western partners and the contractors that supplied ice-capable support vessels, Russia has been unable to pursue major new offshore projects in the Arctic.
A broader problem is that ice-capable vessels need crews experienced in navigating heavy ice. The greatest fear of any icebreaker captain is being hit from behind. This can happen during a rescue operation, when the icebreaker is pulling free a vessel stuck in the ice. With the two ships so close together, the risk of collision is high. The same risk arises when the icebreaker meets unexpectedly thick ice that forces it to slow abruptly. In both cases, the crew of the commercial vessel must be experienced and ready to follow instructions immediately.
Scenarios
Most likely: Russia’s Arctic strategy falters as capability gaps widen
The most likely scenario is one in which Russia falls behind not only in icebreaker construction but also in producing and acquiring commercial vessels that can operate in Arctic waters. With China unable to fill the gap, as its icebreakers lack the necessary power, Russia’s Arctic strategy falters and its hydrocarbon exports suffer.
For other Arctic powers, the decisive question will be which of them have sufficient capabilities and experience across the full spectrum of operations in heavy ice. Canada is likely to emerge as a leading Arctic power, together with Finland, Norway and, despite its procurement choice, Sweden. South Korea may gradually become an unlikely rival to Finland in icebreaker construction. The U.S. will build icebreakers in warm-water states of Texas and Louisiana.
Somewhat likely: Confrontation escalates; Arctic divides into competing blocs
In a somewhat likely scenario, confrontation escalates and sanctions tighten. Russia is excluded from Arctic drilling and it places even greater emphasis on combat icebreakers. Only Russia and China use the NSR, and China deploys its Arctic research vessels for clandestine purposes around Greenland and Iceland. Norway profits by expanding offshore drilling. The U.S. and Canada expand their fleets to counter both a failing Russia and an inexperienced China, while Sweden and Finland dominate winter navigation in the Baltic Sea.
Least likely: Sanctions lifted, Arctic cooperation resumes on commercial terms
In the least likely scenario, commercial considerations drive future developments. Sanctions are lifted, technologies for building icebreakers and ice-class cargo vessels are shared, military confrontation eases and companies revive earlier ambitions for Arctic drilling and developing the NSR as a transport route. Little suggests any of this will happen.
Contact us today for tailored geopolitical insights and industry-specific advisory services.

Sign up for our newsletter
Receive insights from our experts every week in your inbox.
Information about what personal data we collect about you and how we process it (including information about how we personalize our website for you and deliver content tailored to you) can be found in our privacy policy.





